In 2025, Outback and Outbroka were discussing the same mark in two places at once.
In São Paulo Justice, Outback Steakhouse was suing Outbroka Restaurant and Buffet Services for use of the name, visual identity and unfair competition. The judge granted the preliminary injunction. Outbroka appealed. At the Court of Justice, the rapporteur maintained the decision, and the vote that decided the appeal has a title that summarizes this side of the case.
“Preliminary injunction. Violation of trademark right and unfair competition. Outback v. Outbroka.”
TJSP, Interlocutory Appeal 2067248-75.2025.8.26.0000, vote no. 43061
The final judgment ordered Outbroka to stop using the name and to pay compensation for material damages and thirty thousand reais in moral damages.
At the same time, in the Federal Courts of Rio de Janeiro, another proceeding was discussing a different question: whether the OUTBROKA trademark registration itself, granted by INPI in 2024, was valid. The action was filed by Outback against the registration owner, Criar Design Comércio e Serviços de Móveis, and against INPI, seeking nullity of registration No. 929.851.080 and abstention from use. A preliminary injunction suspended the effects of the registration. In its answer, Criar Design asked the Federal Court to recognize connection with the São Paulo case and declare itself the proper venue; the court rejected the request, and the two proceedings kept running in parallel, each within its own jurisdiction.
“INPI’s response, arguing, in a preliminary matter, its procedural position as a necessary co-defendant, and, on the merits, acknowledging that the plaintiff’s claim was well-founded.”
Federal Courts of Rio de Janeiro, Civil Ordinary Proceeding 5003790-58.2025.4.02.5101, INPI’s response to the case file
For those who look at only one of these bases, it is easy to see only half the story. Whoever follows the mark only through INPI publications sees the nullity action in Rio; whoever follows only the State Courts sees the dispute over use in São Paulo. The two are the same commercial fight, seen by two systems that do not talk to each other.
The outcome came from outside both courts. In April 2026, Criar Design filed with INPI a request to assign the OUTBROKA registration to Outback Steakhouse of Florida, LLC. INPI granted the transfer in September 2026 (RPI 2905): today, Outback is the owner of the very registration that triggered the nullity action.
This case helps explain a pattern that emerged when TrademarkIQ cross-referenced INPI’s records with court publications.
The finding
A TrademarkIQ survey identified 5,580 lawsuits linked to 2,604 owners whose trademark was confirmed by INPI itself as involved in some judicial proceeding. Among these lawsuits, 2,329, or 41.7%, are pending in State Courts. That is not a residual slice. It is nearly half of a universe that, seen only through INPI’s lens, would look almost entirely federal.
And that last sentence is not a figure of speech. It is, literally, what the data show when the measurement method changes.
Two ways to measure, two very different maps
When formally notified of a judicial proceeding involving a trademark, INPI may reflect that in the Industrial Property Gazette, in the so-called judicial proceeding notification. If the question were “where do the proceedings INPI annotates run”, the answer would be nearly unanimous: 99.1% in the Federal Courts. What predominates in this set of annotations are precisely the proceedings that directly affect the registration and involve INPI’s own involvement, especially actions over validity, a matter the law reserves for the Federal Courts.
When you follow the same owners into the courts, without depending on INPI having been notified, the picture changes: 58.3% Federal, 41.7% State. The gap between 99% and 58% shows the size of the area that disappears when the map is built from INPI alone. Whoever monitors a trademark by reading only INPI publications sees almost exclusively nullity actions. They miss everything two competitors dispute without that, on its own, producing a new annotation on the trademark: improper use, similar packaging, unfair competition, damages.
The Outback v. Outbroka case shows the mechanism in action. The proceeding INPI annotated was exactly the nullity action in Rio, filed against the registration itself. The dispute over use in São Paulo never generated its own annotation on the Outback trademark: it shows up in the data because TrademarkIQ traced the owner’s name into the Court Gazette, not because INPI recorded it.
Chart 1
The same holders, two very different maps
Distribution by jurisdiction according to the method used to identify proceedings linked to the holders.
Source: TIQ-Juris™, cross-referencing trademark holders confirmed by INPI (IPAS462/IPAS639) with the National Electronic Justice Gazette. Reference base: September 22, 2026.
It is not a rare pattern. The Sixfit gym went through the same design, and its case shows even more directly the root of the separation: why a state judge refuses, purposefully, to rule on the trademark.
“This state court does not have jurisdiction”
In Campinas, the Sixfit gym chain registered its trademark with INPI in 2018. In 2023, a chain called Six Sport Life, then restricted to Brasília, registered its own trademark, also with INPI. In 2024, Six Sport Life opened a branch in São Paulo. Sixfit sued in São Paulo state court asking that the rival stop using the name, alleging customer confusion.
The judge denied the preliminary injunction. Both trademarks have valid registrations with INPI: deciding which one prevails would, in practice, mean ruling on the validity of a registration. Two gyms, two valid registrations, and a very concrete limit on what that state court could decide.
“The validity or eventual nullity of a trademark registration is a matter for the Federal Courts (...) this state court, in a preliminary and summary proceeding, has no jurisdiction to set aside the effects of a registration duly issued by INPI, on pain of usurping jurisdiction.”
TJSP, Civil Ordinary Proceeding 1018595-08.2025.8.26.0114, preliminary injunction ruling
The judge was not pointing to a hypothetical path: Sixfit had already opened that other front. In the Federal Courts of Rio de Janeiro, the gym also filed, also in 2025, an action against Six Sport Life and INPI seeking a declaration of nullity of the “SIX SPORT LIFE” registration (No. 932.711.774) and a permanent injunction against its use. It is the same design as the Outback case: use and visual identity in State Courts, registration validity in Federal Courts, both proceedings running at the same time, filed by the same plaintiff.
It is Theme 950 of the Superior Court of Justice (STJ) at work in real time: set in 2018, in a case between Natura and Jequiti over product packaging, the precedent established that trademark nullity, because it involves INPI, falls to the Federal Courts; use, unfair competition and trade dress, being disputes between private parties, fall to the State Courts.
When the product in dispute is a bottle of juice
In Brazil’s Serra Gaúcha wine region, Panizzon Beverages sued Basso Wines and Spirits over the packaging of a grape juice. After a technical expert opinion, the judgment ruled in favor of Panizzon.
State Courts · trade dress
Sociedade de Bebidas Panizzon v. Basso Vinhos e Espumantes
TJRS, Civil Ordinary Proceeding 5000764-07.2021.8.21.0097 · filed in 2021, on appeal as of September 2026
Basso was ordered to “permanently” stop using the trade dress that “imitates or reproduces” that of Panizzon grape juice, under a daily fine, plus lost-profits damages calculated on the revenue improperly obtained (art. 210 of the LPI, Brazil’s IP law) and thirty thousand reais in moral damages.
Five years between filing and the appeal ruling: the case is still active as of September 2026.
It is not an isolated case. Among the subjects most cited across the survey’s 5,580 proceedings, after Trademark and Trademark Registration themselves, come Moral Damages (218 proceedings) and Material Damages (199), a sign that a good share of these actions do not just ask the other side to stop, they ask for money.
A portfolio is also defense work
A registered trademark is not only an asset to protect. It is also a position you are obligated to defend, case by case. Among the confirmed owners who appear as a party in intellectual-property disputes, 1,181 appear only as plaintiffs, 886 only as defendants, and 532 appear on both sides, in different proceedings.
Two fronts, the same owner
Bulgari S.p.A.
TJSP 1126946-30.2019.8.26.0100 (plaintiff) · STJ, Interlocutory Appeal in AREsp 3146813/SP (defense)
In São Paulo, Bulgari filed, together with six other luxury brands (Burberry, Cartier, Montblanc, Hugo Boss, Goyard and Sporloisirs), a joint action against a single company, Maxim Administração e Participações. The claim was upheld, and the case is still, years later, in the judgment-enforcement phase.
In the same period, Bulgari had to defend, all the way to the Superior Court of Justice, an earlier win against an appeal filed by a cosmetics company trying to overturn the decision. Attacking on one front and holding a position on another, at the same time, in different courts: that is what it looks like, in practice, to own a valuable trademark.
None of it is free, either. Nearly one in five proceedings in the survey (19%) is no longer arguing the merits of the dispute: it is in the judgment-enforcement phase, meaning someone has already won and is now trying to collect. And the pattern is not historical: 78% of the 5,580 proceedings had some activity in the last twelve months.
When litigating becomes routine
Among 2,604 identified owners, 73 have ten or more proceedings. Only two exceed fifty, and both come from football: Confederação Brasileira de Futebol (the Brazilian Football Confederation, CBF) appears in 369 proceedings, Sport Club Internacional in 104.
Concentration
Confederação Brasileira de Futebol
422 distinct defendants identified, mostly small businesses, in the judgment-enforcement phase
What can be said with confidence, from the available case files: most of CBF’s proceedings no longer argue anything at all, they are in the collection phase, against hundreds of different defendants, mostly small businesses. In a sample we read in full, a sporting-goods store in the interior of São Paulo was billed R$ 10,210.20; a gift shop, R$ 10,608.72.
Similar amounts, small defendants, proceedings that are no longer about what happened, they are about collecting what has already been decided. What cannot be known from the available publications is what conduct triggered each of these charges. That is why the survey does not attribute a common cause to these proceedings.
Chart 2
Where the identified litigation concentrates
The ten courts with the most identified proceedings, among the 5,580 in the survey.
Source: TIQ-Juris™, cross-referencing trademark owners confirmed by INPI with the National Electronic Justice Gazette. Reference base: September 22, 2026.
What this changes
For anyone managing a trademark portfolio, the implication is direct. Watching only INPI publications shows a slice of the problem, and a skewed one: mostly nullity actions, in the Federal Courts, involving the institute itself. The other half of the phenomenon, disputes over use, packaging, unfair competition, damages, plays out elsewhere, under a different rule: much of that dimension can unfold without producing the kind of judicial annotation you would normally find by tracking only a trademark’s administrative life at INPI.
A trademark can be administratively quiet, with no opposition and no nullity proceeding underway, and still be in the middle of a judicial dispute that checking its administrative life at INPI, alone, would not reveal.
Methodology and limitationsViewClose
What the data do not prove
The design is observational. The numbers show where the identified litigation sits, not why it arises, and the gap between 99% and 58% Federal, depending on the method, shows that the measurement channel changes the result decisively.
The owner base used (2,604 names) comes from trademarks INPI has already annotated as involved in some judicial proceeding, which tends to favor larger owners with a longer litigation history; smaller trademarks, without a prior annotation, fall outside this set.
The National Electronic Justice Gazette only covers publications from roughly 2020 onward, which under-represents older, already-closed proceedings. And matching the owner’s name at INPI to the party name in the Gazette requires an exact match, which misses spelling variants and changed corporate names: the federal nullity action Sixfit itself filed was left out of the count because the Gazette records the defendant as “Six Sport Life Participações Ltda.”, with a period, while INPI’s annotation uses “Ltda”, without one. The case is real and documented in this report, but it is not among the 5,580 proceedings totaled in the chart.
How we calculated this
Universe. Owners whose trademark was formally confirmed by INPI as the subject of a judicial proceeding (Notification of Judicial Proceeding and Final Judicial Decision annotations, published in the Industrial Property Gazette), cross-referenced with all proceedings on an intellectual-property subject matter (CNJ’s Unified Procedural Table) in which those same owners appear as a party, per the National Electronic Justice Gazette.
Exclusions. Annotations for liens, attachments or freezes, where the trademark is merely an asset seized in an enforcement of a different nature, and proceedings identified only by number, without a confirmed intellectual-property subject matter.
Jurisdiction and party role. Jurisdiction classified by the proceeding’s court of origin. Party role (plaintiff/defendant) uses the original role in the action, not a role reversed on appeal.
Named cases. Every case cited in the text was read in full in the official publications before it entered the report; where the merits reasoning was not available, the case was dropped or the limitation was disclosed in the text.
Reference date. September 22, 2026.
Sources
Cases and rulings cited
- TJSP, Civil Ordinary Proceeding 1006652-36.2025.8.26.0100 — Outback v. Outbroka, trial court
- TJSP, Interlocutory Appeal 2067248-75.2025.8.26.0000 — Outback v. Outbroka, appeal of the preliminary injunction
- TRF2, Civil Ordinary Proceeding 5003790-58.2025.4.02.5101 — Outback v. Outbroka/Criar Design, trademark nullity
- TJSP, Civil Ordinary Proceeding 1018595-08.2025.8.26.0114 — Sixfit v. Six Sport Life, state-court injunction
- TRF2, Civil Ordinary Proceeding 5100439-85.2025.4.02.5101 — Sixfit v. Six Sport Life, trademark nullity
- TJRS, Civil Ordinary Proceeding 5000764-07.2021.8.21.0097 — Panizzon v. Basso Vinhos e Espumantes
- TJSP, Civil Ordinary Proceeding 1126946-30.2019.8.26.0100 — Bulgari and others v. Maxim Administração e Participações
- STJ, Interlocutory Appeal in AREsp 3146813/SP — Bulgari, defense on appeal

About the author
Ricardo Vinhas
Founder of TrademarkIQ
Ricardo Vinhas is the founder of TrademarkIQ and a specialist in strategy and data intelligence. He holds a bachelor’s degree in Statistics from the Federal University of Bahia and a master’s degree in Statistics and Information Management, with a specialization in Marketing Research and CRM, from the NOVA Information Management School, NOVA University Lisbon, where he also completed a postgraduate program in Digital Enterprise Management. In 2026, he completed the Certification in Intellectual Property Law & Strategy from the WIPO Academy and INPI.
